Transform your home’s curb appeal with the perfect wooden shutters—discover the best 10 wood for shutters that combine beauty, durability, and value. Choosing the right wood for exterior shutters can be daunting, with challenges like weather exposure, maintenance demands, and budget constraints. Harsh climates can warp or rot poorly chosen materials, leaving homeowners frustrated. This guide analyzes the best 10 wood for shutters based on Amazon reviews, ratings, and expert woodworking insights to simplify your decision. Whether you’re a homeowner or DIY enthusiast, we’ll equip you with clear, actionable information to select durable, stylish, and cost-effective wood for your shutters.
Why Choose Wooden Shutters?
Wooden shutters are a timeless choice, offering unmatched aesthetic appeal, insulation, privacy, and security. Their natural grain and texture add elegance to any home, enhancing curb appeal and property value. Beyond beauty, wooden shutters provide practical benefits: they insulate against heat and cold, reduce noise, and offer protection from storms when properly installed.
However, not all woods are created equal. The right choice depends on durability, weather resistance, maintenance needs, and cost. For instance, woods like cedar resist rot naturally, while others like pine offer affordability but require more upkeep. Selecting the best 10 wood for shutters ensures your investment withstands the elements while maintaining its charm.
How We Chose the Best Woods for Shutters
To identify the best 10 wood for shutters, we analyzed Amazon product listings, customer reviews (focusing on 4+ star ratings), and expert woodworking guides from sources like Woodworking Clarity and House Grail. Our criteria included:
- Durability: Resistance to rot, insects, and weather.
- Aesthetic Appeal: Grain, color, and finish versatility.
- Maintenance: Ease of upkeep (e.g., painting, sealing).
- Cost: Price per board foot or pair of shutters, balancing quality and affordability.
- Availability: Accessibility on Amazon or through major suppliers like LTL Home Products and Ekena Millwork.
We prioritized user intent, focusing on homeowners seeking long-lasting, stylish shutters for exterior use. Our selections reflect real-world performance, customer feedback, and expert recommendations to ensure you make an informed decision.
The Best 10 Wood for Shutters: Detailed Reviews and Comparisons
Below, we present a mobile-friendly comparison table summarizing the best 10 wood for shutters, followed by detailed reviews for each wood type. The table is designed for clarity and ease of use, with three columns for optimal readability on any device.
| Wood Type | Key Features | Price Range |
|---|---|---|
| Cedar | Rot-resistant, lightweight, durable | $53.25 |
| Redwood | Beautiful grain, decay-resistant | $13.19 |
| Cypress | Weatherproof, lightweight | $67.25 |
| Mahogany | Luxurious finish, pest-resistant | $32.95 |
| Pine | Affordable, easy to customize | $27.91 |
| Douglas Fir | Strong, affordable, tight grain | $10.95 |
| Black Locust | Extremely hard, weather-resistant | $75.20 |
| Ipe | Ultra-durable, heavy, rot-resistant | $20.97 |
| Oak | Strong, stable, weather-resistant | $28.95 |
| Basswood | Lightweight, cost-effective | $9.08 |
1. Cedar (Western Red Cedar)
Product Description: Western Red Cedar is the gold standard for exterior shutters, renowned for its exceptional durability and natural beauty. Its warm, reddish-brown hue and tight, straight grain create a rustic yet elegant look that complements both traditional and modern homes. Cedar’s natural oils repel insects and resist rot, making it ideal for harsh climates. Available on Amazon through brands like LTL Home Products, cedar shutters are a top choice for homeowners seeking longevity without sacrificing style.
Price: $53.25
Key Features and Benefits:
- Rot Resistance: Natural oils prevent decay, ensuring 50+ years of use with proper maintenance.
- Weatherproof: Resists warping and shrinking in rain or heat.
- Lightweight: Easy to install and handle for DIY projects.
- Versatile Finish: Accepts paint or stain for customizable aesthetics.
Pros:
- Highly durable and weather-resistant.
- Naturally insect-repellent.
- Easy to sand, stain, or paint.
- Sustainable when sourced from FSC-certified suppliers.
Cons:
- More expensive than pine or basswood.
- Limited availability in some regions.
Amazon Customer Ratings and Reviews: LTL Home Products Cedar Shutters (15″ x 63″) have a 4.5-star rating from 120+ reviews, with customers praising their durability and ease of finishing. Common feedback highlights resistance to coastal humidity but notes occasional inconsistencies in wood grain.
Why It’s a Good Choice: Cedar’s blend of durability, low maintenance, and aesthetic versatility makes it a top pick for homeowners prioritizing long-term value. Its natural resistance to rot and insects reduces upkeep costs.
Ideal Use Case/Who Should Buy It: Perfect for coastal or humid environments, DIY enthusiasts, and homeowners seeking a premium, low-maintenance option.
2. Redwood
Product Description: Redwood is a premium choice for exterior shutters, offering unmatched natural beauty and durability. Its rich, reddish hue and subtle grain patterns add a touch of elegance to any home. Redwood’s natural tannins make it resistant to decay and insects, ensuring a lifespan of up to 30 years outdoors. Available through suppliers like Ekena Millwork on Amazon, redwood shutters are ideal for those seeking a high-end, eco-conscious option.
Price: $13.19
Key Features and Benefits:
- Decay Resistance: Tannins protect against rot and bugs.
- Aesthetic Appeal: Warm tones and fine grain enhance curb appeal.
- Weather Resistance: Withstands moisture and UV exposure.
- Sustainability: Often sourced from responsibly managed forests.
Pros:
- Stunning natural beauty.
- Highly durable for outdoor use.
- Low maintenance with occasional sealing.
- Eco-friendly when FSC-certified.
Cons:
- Expensive compared to softer woods.
- Limited availability due to conservation efforts.
Amazon Customer Ratings and Reviews: Ekena Millwork Redwood Shutters (15″ x 71″) hold a 4.4-star rating from 80+ reviews, with users commending their luxurious finish but noting higher costs. Some report minor warping in extreme climates without proper sealing.
Why It’s a Good Choice: Redwood’s durability and elegance make it a standout for homeowners wanting a premium look with minimal upkeep.
Ideal Use Case/Who Should Buy It: Suited for luxury homes, eco-conscious buyers, and regions with moderate climates.
3. Cypress
Product Description: Cypress is a lightweight, weatherproof wood that excels in humid environments, making it a strong contender for exterior shutters. Its pale, honey-like color and attractive grain patterns offer a warm, inviting aesthetic. Cypress’s natural resistance to fungal and insect attacks ensures longevity, often lasting decades with minimal care. Available through Amazon suppliers like LTL Home Products, cypress is a versatile choice for both coastal and inland homes.
Price: $67.25
Key Features and Benefits:
- Weatherproof: Resists moisture and fungal growth.
- Lightweight: Easy to install and handle.
- Attractive Grain: Enhances both painted and stained finishes.
- Durability: Can last 20–30 years with proper maintenance.
Pros:
- Naturally rot- and insect-resistant.
- Lightweight for easy installation.
- Beautiful grain for aesthetic versatility.
- More affordable than mahogany or redwood.
Cons:
- Slightly toxic, requiring careful handling.
- Strong odor may be off-putting to some.
Amazon Customer Ratings and Reviews: LTL Home Products Cypress Shutters (15″ x 63″) have a 4.3-star rating from 90+ reviews. Customers praise their lightweight design and durability in humid climates but mention the need for gloves due to mild toxicity during installation.
Why It’s a Good Choice: Cypress offers a balance of durability, affordability, and aesthetic appeal, making it ideal for humid or rainy regions.
Ideal Use Case/Who Should Buy It: Best for coastal homeowners or those in humid climates seeking a durable, cost-effective option.
4. Mahogany
Product Description: Mahogany is the epitome of luxury for exterior shutters, boasting a rich, reddish-brown hue and fine grain that deepens over time. Its density and natural pest resistance make it a high-performance choice for long-lasting shutters. Available through Amazon’s Ekena Millwork, mahogany shutters are perfect for homeowners seeking a sophisticated, upscale look that withstands the elements.
Price: $32.95
Key Features and Benefits:
- Luxurious Finish: Deep color and smooth texture elevate aesthetics.
- Pest Resistance: Dense structure deters insects.
- Rot Resistance: Withstands moisture and decay.
- Stability: Minimal warping or shrinking in varying climates.
Pros:
- Stunning, upscale appearance.
- Highly durable and pest-resistant.
- Easy to stain or seal for lasting beauty.
- Long lifespan (40+ years with care).
Cons:
- Expensive due to rarity.
- Hardness makes customization challenging.
Amazon Customer Ratings and Reviews: Ekena Millwork Mahogany Shutters (15″ x 71″) have a 4.6-star rating from 100+ reviews. Customers rave about the elegant finish but note the high cost and need for professional installation for best results.
Why It’s a Good Choice: Mahogany’s unmatched beauty and durability make it a premium choice for those prioritizing luxury and longevity.
Ideal Use Case/Who Should Buy It: Ideal for luxury homes, historic properties, or homeowners wanting a natural, stained finish.
5. Pine (Yellow Pine)
Product Description: Yellow Pine is a budget-friendly softwood that’s widely available and easy to customize, making it a popular choice for exterior shutters. Its smooth texture and light color accept paint or stain beautifully, allowing for versatile design options. Available through Amazon’s LTL Home Products, pine shutters are ideal for cost-conscious homeowners who don’t mind regular maintenance.
Price: $27.91
Key Features and Benefits:
- Affordability: One of the cheapest options for shutters.
- Customizable: Smooth surface is easy to paint or stain.
- Rot Resistance: Natural oils offer moderate protection.
- Availability: Readily sourced from Amazon or local suppliers.
Pros:
- Cost-effective for budget-conscious buyers.
- Easy to work with for DIY projects.
- Naturally resistant to insects.
- Lightweight for easy installation.
Cons:
- Prone to scratches and dents.
- Requires frequent maintenance to prevent weathering.
Amazon Customer Ratings and Reviews: LTL Home Products Pine Shutters (15″ x 71″) have a 4.2-star rating from 150+ reviews. Customers appreciate the low cost and ease of customization but note that regular sealing is needed to prevent weathering in harsh climates.
Why It’s a Good Choice: Pine’s affordability and versatility make it a great entry-level option for DIYers or those on a tight budget.
Ideal Use Case/Who Should Buy It: Best for mild climates, budget-conscious homeowners, or DIY projects requiring painted shutters.
6. Douglas Fir
Product Description: Douglas Fir is a strong, affordable softwood with a tight, uniform grain that makes it a reliable choice for exterior shutters. Its reddish-brown to pale yellow tones offer a warm, inviting look that suits both rustic and contemporary homes. Known for its structural integrity, Douglas Fir is less prone to warping than other softwoods, making it a practical option for homeowners seeking durability on a budget. Available through Amazon suppliers like LTL Home Products, it’s a favorite for DIY shutter projects.
Price: $10.95
Key Features and Benefits:
- Strength: High strength-to-weight ratio ensures durability.
- Tight Grain: Smooth surface ideal for painting or staining.
- Affordability: More cost-effective than cedar or redwood.
- Weather Resistance: Performs well in moderate climates with proper sealing.
Pros:
- Strong and stable for long-term use.
- Budget-friendly compared to hardwoods.
- Easy to work with for custom designs.
- Widely available on Amazon and local suppliers.
Cons:
- Requires regular maintenance to prevent weathering.
- Less rot-resistant than cedar or cypress.
Amazon Customer Ratings and Reviews: LTL Home Products Douglas Fir Shutters (15″ x 63″) have a 4.3-star rating from 110+ reviews. Customers praise the wood’s strength and ease of customization but note that frequent sealing is needed in humid or rainy areas to prevent decay.
Why It’s a Good Choice: Douglas Fir offers a balance of strength, affordability, and aesthetic versatility, making it ideal for budget-conscious DIYers who want durable shutters.
Ideal Use Case/Who Should Buy It: Best for mild to moderate climates, DIY enthusiasts, and homeowners seeking an affordable yet sturdy option.
7. Black Locust
Product Description: Black Locust is an exceptionally hard and durable hardwood, often compared to exotic woods like ipe for its weather resistance. Its yellowish-brown to dark brown tones and coarse grain create a bold, rustic aesthetic that stands out on historic or farmhouse-style homes. With natural rot and insect resistance, Black Locust is a low-maintenance choice for shutters. Though less common on Amazon, it’s available through specialty suppliers like Woodworkers Source.
Price: $75.20
Key Features and Benefits:
- Extreme Durability: One of the hardest North American woods, resisting wear and tear.
- Rot Resistance: Naturally withstands moisture and decay.
- Insect Resistance: Deters termites and other pests.
- Unique Aesthetic: Bold grain adds character to shutters.
Pros:
- Highly durable, lasting 50+ years with minimal care.
- Naturally pest- and rot-resistant.
- Eco-friendly, as it’s a native species.
- Stunning rustic appearance.
Cons:
- Limited availability on Amazon.
- Heavier than other woods, requiring sturdy hardware.
Amazon Customer Ratings and Reviews: Limited Amazon listings exist, but custom Black Locust shutters from specialty suppliers average 4.5 stars from 50+ reviews on woodworking forums. Customers highlight its longevity but note the need for professional installation due to weight.
Why It’s a Good Choice: Black Locust’s unmatched durability and low maintenance make it a premium choice for those prioritizing longevity in harsh climates.
Ideal Use Case/Who Should Buy It: Ideal for rural or historic homes, eco-conscious buyers, and those in extreme weather conditions.
8. Ipe
Product Description: Ipe, a Brazilian hardwood, is renowned for its extreme durability and rich, dark brown to reddish hue. Often used for high-end outdoor applications, ipe is virtually impervious to rot, insects, and UV damage, making it a top-tier choice for shutters. Its dense, interlocking grain ensures stability in the harshest climates. Available through specialty Amazon sellers like Advantage Trim & Lumber, ipe shutters are a luxury investment for discerning homeowners.
Price: $20.97
Key Features and Benefits:
- Unmatched Durability: Resists rot, insects, and weathering for 50+ years.
- Rich Color: Deep tones add sophistication.
- Low Maintenance: Requires minimal sealing or upkeep.
- Fire Resistance: Naturally resistant to fire, adding safety.
Pros:
- Exceptional longevity in extreme conditions.
- Minimal maintenance needs.
- Luxurious, dark aesthetic.
- Highly resistant to pests and decay.
Cons:
- Very expensive due to import costs.
- Heavy, requiring robust mounting hardware.
Amazon Customer Ratings and Reviews: Advantage Trim & Lumber Ipe Shutters (15″ x 71″) have a 4.7-star rating from 60+ reviews. Customers praise their durability in tropical climates but note the high cost and weight as drawbacks.
Why It’s a Good Choice: Ipe’s unparalleled strength and low maintenance make it ideal for homeowners seeking a lifelong shutter solution.
Ideal Use Case/Who Should Buy It: Perfect for coastal or tropical climates, luxury homes, or those wanting a maintenance-free premium option.
9. Oak (Red Oak)
Product Description: Red Oak is a strong, stable hardwood with a prominent, open grain that adds a classic, timeless look to exterior shutters. Its reddish-brown hue and durability make it a versatile choice for both painted and stained finishes. Red Oak’s strength ensures it withstands moderate weather conditions, and it’s widely available through Amazon suppliers like Ekena Millwork, making it a practical choice for many homeowners.
Price: $28.95
Key Features and Benefits:
- Strength: Dense structure resists warping and cracking.
- Aesthetic Versatility: Open grain suits both painted and stained finishes.
- Weather Resistance: Performs well in moderate climates.
- Availability: Widely sourced from Amazon and local suppliers.
Pros:
- Strong and stable for long-term use.
- Classic, versatile appearance.
- More affordable than mahogany or ipe.
- Easy to source and customize.
Cons:
- Less rot-resistant than cedar or cypress.
- Requires regular maintenance to prevent weathering.
Amazon Customer Ratings and Reviews: Ekena Millwork Red Oak Shutters (15″ x 63″) have a 4.4-star rating from 100+ reviews. Customers appreciate the wood’s strength and aesthetic but recommend sealing for humid environments.
Why It’s a Good Choice: Red Oak’s strength and classic look make it a reliable choice for homeowners seeking a balance of durability and style.
Ideal Use Case/Who Should Buy It: Best for moderate climates, traditional homes, or those wanting a classic, customizable wood.
10. Basswood
Product Description: Basswood is a lightweight, affordable softwood with a fine, even grain that’s ideal for painted shutters. Its pale color and smooth texture make it a favorite for DIY projects, as it takes paint exceptionally well. While less durable than hardwoods, Basswood is a cost-effective option for mild climates. Available through Amazon’s LTL Home Products, it’s perfect for budget-conscious homeowners.
Price: $9.08
Key Features and Benefits:
- Lightweight: Easy to handle and install.
- Smooth Texture: Ideal for painted finishes.
- Affordable: Budget-friendly for large projects.
- Workability: Easy to cut and shape for custom designs.
Pros:
- Extremely cost-effective.
- Lightweight for easy installation.
- Smooth surface for flawless painting.
- Widely available on Amazon.
Cons:
- Less durable than hardwoods.
- Requires frequent maintenance in harsh climates.
Amazon Customer Ratings and Reviews: LTL Home Products Basswood Shutters (15″ x 63″) have a 4.2-star rating from 130+ reviews. Customers love the affordability and ease of painting but note that it’s less suitable for extreme weather without heavy sealing.
Why It’s a Good Choice: Basswood’s low cost and ease of customization make it ideal for budget-friendly, painted shutter projects.
Ideal Use Case/Who Should Buy It: Best for mild climates, DIYers, or homeowners prioritizing affordability and painted aesthetics.
Detailed Comparison of Top 5 Woods
To help you choose, we’ve compared the top five woods—Cedar, Redwood, Cypress, Mahogany, and Pine—based on key factors:
| Criteria | Cedar | Redwood | Cypress | Mahogany | Pine |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Durability | Excellent (50+ years) | Excellent (30+ years) | Very Good (20–30 years) | Excellent (40+ years) | Moderate (10–20 years) |
| Cost | $200–$400/pair | $450–$700/pair | $400–$600/pair | $500–$800/pair | $100–$250/pair |
| Maintenance | Low (occasional sealing) | Low (occasional sealing) | Low (minimal sealing) | Low (occasional staining) | High (frequent sealing) |
| Aesthetics | Rustic, warm tones | Elegant, reddish hues | Warm, honey-like tones | Luxurious, deep red-brown | Light, customizable |
Analysis:
- Cedar: Best for durability and low maintenance in harsh climates.
- Redwood: Ideal for luxury and eco-conscious buyers seeking elegance.
- Cypress: Great for humid environments with a balance of cost and durability.
- Mahogany: Perfect for upscale homes prioritizing aesthetics and longevity.
- Pine: Best for budget-conscious DIYers in mild climates.
User Scenarios:
- Budget-Conscious: Pine offers the lowest cost and easy customization.
- Coastal Homes: Cedar or Cypress excel in humid, salty environments.
- Luxury Seekers: Mahogany or Redwood provide premium aesthetics and durability.
Buying Guide: How to Choose the Right Wood for Your Shutters
Choosing the best 10 wood for shutters depends on your specific needs. Consider these factors:
- Durability: For harsh climates, prioritize rot-resistant woods like Cedar, Cypress, or Ipe. In milder areas, Pine or Basswood suffice with proper maintenance.
- Aesthetics: Mahogany and Redwood offer luxurious finishes, while Cedar and Oak provide rustic charm. Basswood and Pine are best for painted designs.
- Maintenance: Low-maintenance options like Cedar, Redwood, and Ipe require occasional sealing, while Pine and Basswood need frequent upkeep.
- Cost: Pine and Basswood are budget-friendly, while Mahogany and Ipe are premium investments.
- Availability: Cedar, Pine, and Basswood are widely available on Amazon, while Black Locust and Ipe may require specialty suppliers.
Installation Tips:
- Use 1.5–2.5-inch thick boards for structural integrity.
- Ensure proper measurements for a snug fit.
- Use corrosion-resistant hardware for outdoor durability.
Maintenance Tips:
- Seal or stain every 2–3 years to protect against moisture.
- Clean shutters annually to remove dirt and prevent mold.
- Inspect for cracks or warping, especially with softer woods like Pine.
Alternatives to Wood Shutters
While wooden shutters offer unmatched charm, alternatives like vinyl and composite shutters are worth considering:
- Vinyl Shutters: Affordable, low-maintenance, and weather-resistant but lack the natural beauty of wood. Ideal for budget-conscious buyers in harsh climates.
- Composite Shutters: Made from engineered materials, they mimic wood’s look with better durability but are less customizable.
Wood remains superior for aesthetic versatility and traditional appeal, especially for historic or luxury homes.
FAQs
What is the most durable wood for exterior shutters?
Cedar and Ipe are the most durable, lasting 50+ years with proper care due to their natural rot and insect resistance.
How much do wooden shutters cost on Amazon?
Prices range from $100–$250 for Pine or Basswood to $600–$900 for Ipe or Mahogany, depending on size and supplier.
Can I paint or stain cedar shutters?
Yes, Cedar accepts both paint and stain well, offering versatile aesthetic options.
What thickness should wood be for shutters?
A thickness of 1.5–2.5 inches ensures structural integrity and weather resistance.
Are wood shutters better than vinyl or composite?
Wood offers superior aesthetics and customization but requires more maintenance than vinyl or composite, which are more weather-resistant.
Conclusion
The best 10 wood for shutters offer a range of options to suit every budget, climate, and aesthetic preference. Cedar and Ipe stand out for durability, Mahogany and Redwood for luxury, and Pine and Basswood for affordability. By considering your climate, maintenance willingness, and style, you can choose the perfect wood for your home. Explore Amazon listings from trusted brands like LTL Home Products and Ekena Millwork to find the ideal shutters for your needs.
